Skip to content

The quote went quiet: why customers stall on a big decision and how to follow up

Why customers who asked for a quote stop replying, what a study of 2.5 million sales calls found about indecision, and a follow-up plan that helps them decide.

6 min read

In short: when a customer goes quiet after a quote for an expensive service, the usual reason is not a cheaper competitor but indecision. They are afraid of choosing wrong. A follow-up that only asks “any news?” adds pressure; one that removes a doubt helps them decide.

Below: what research on sales conversations says about indecision, why expensive purchases stall, a follow-up plan in four messages, what to avoid, and how to put a number on the quotes you lose today.

Silence after a quote is usually “no decision”, not “no”

Matthew Dixon and Ted McKenna analysed 2.5 million recorded sales conversations for their book The JOLT Effect. In their own summary of the research (opens in a new tab), between 40% and 60% of qualified opportunities are lost to “no decision”: the customer buys neither from you nor from a competitor.

The level of indecision changes the outcome. In Challenger’s write-up of the same study (opens in a new tab), calls with medium indecision (about 60% of the calls analysed) ended in a sale 30% of the time; calls with high indecision (about 30% of the calls) only 6% of the time.

The study looked at sales calls recorded on Zoom, Teams, Webex and other platforms (opens in a new tab). A quote for a renovation, a car, an event venue or a dental implant is a different purchase, but the mechanism carries over: the higher the price, the more a wrong choice costs, and the easier it is to put the decision off.

What makes a customer put off a big decision

Indecision rarely looks like indecision. Usually it looks like this:

  • the quote offers several options and the customer cannot tell which one fits them;
  • they do not know what happens after they say yes: who comes, when, what they need to prepare;
  • they have a question they did not ask: paying in instalments, a particular date, the guarantee, what happens if something goes wrong;
  • they are afraid the result will not look the way they imagine;
  • nothing makes deciding today better than deciding next month.

Each of these has an answer you can give in one short message. That is what a good follow-up does.

A follow-up plan in four messages

The plan below follows what Dixon and McKenna saw the best salespeople do (they call it JOLT: judge the indecision, offer your recommendation, limit the exploration, take risk off the table). Match the pace to how fast your customers usually decide:

  • Message 1, the next working day: check the quote arrived and ask one open question, for example “Is anything in the quote unclear, or would you like us to change something?”
  • Message 2, a few days later: give your recommendation. “If I were in your place, I would choose option B, because…” A customer who is afraid of getting it wrong is relieved when an expert chooses with them.
  • Message 3: take risk off the table. Say plainly what happens if something goes wrong: the guarantee, the payment schedule, the cancellation terms. Only what you really offer.
  • Message 4, the closing one: tell them you are closing the request and that they are welcome back any time. It takes the pressure off and often brings the reply that never came.

If the customer asked you to come back on a set date, come back exactly then and skip the rest of the plan.

What not to do

  • Do not invent a deadline or a discount that does not exist. The authors found that urgency tactics (“fear of missing out”) only deepen the customer’s anxiety and fear of failure (opens in a new tab).
  • Do not send the same “any news?” message three times. Every message should bring something new: an answer, a recommendation, a guarantee.
  • Do not add options. A customer who cannot choose between two options does not need a third.
  • Do not keep writing after the closing message, unless the customer comes back.

What the quiet quotes cost you

You can put a number on it with your own data. The quote follow-up calculator asks for four things: how many quotes you send a month, how many customers go quiet after the price, how many of them you get back to, and the average value of a customer. It shows how many customers you lose every month to silence.

Where an assistant helps

Follow-up is the part that gets forgotten in a busy week, so Theron does it for you. After a price or a quote, the customer gets a few short follow-ups over the following month; they stop as soon as the customer books, asks not to be contacted or needs a person. When a conversation needs a person, you get an alert and can answer the customer from your portal.

Want to see how it would work for your quotes? Book a short call and we will look at it together.

Sources

  1. Matthew Dixon, "The best way to get a customer off the fence? Get to know them", Raconteur, 4 July 2023 (the JOLT Effect study of 2.5 million sales calls) (opens in a new tab)
  2. Challenger, "How to Overcome Customer Indecision Using the JOLT Effect Approach" (opens in a new tab)

Read next

See how it would work for you.

In a short call we look at the enquiries you get and how Theron would handle them.